Redistricting “power grab” of African American seats: No, we’re not being “too sensitive”

Email Print Twitter Facebook MySpace Stumble Digg More Destinations
Anthony Asadullah Samad, Ph.D.  |   OW Contributing Columnist

Between the Lines

The California Citizens Redistricting Commission (CCRC) will be voting on the final iteration of redistricting maps this week. These maps are supposed to reflect the demographic shifts in the state’s population following the 2010 Census.

As far as the congressional seats go, the goal of the collective African American community statewide is to hold on to what it has, despite a population that is declining. According to the 2010 Census, Blacks in California represent 6.2 percent of the state’s population, or 2.3 million (out of 37 million residents) who identify themselves as being of African descent. That is down from 7.65 percent of the state’s population after the 2000 Census. California’s Black population is the largest in the west, and the fifth largest in the nation. Of California’s 53 congressional districts, African Americans hold four, or 7.5 percent of the seats (proportional to its percentage in the 2000 Census population). The CCRC now claims that Blacks are over represented in the state’s congressional delegation. Their mindset was reflected in the maps released.

In one of the latest CCRC district maps that was defeated after a pitched battle, seats historically held by African American representatives, commonly referred to as “the Black seats,” had fewer Blacks in those districts making it much more difficult to continue the legacy of African American representation.

In the most dramatic scenario, one commissioner presented maps where two of the seats were merged into one, creating a majority Black district, but losing a “Black” seat in the process.

Relegating the statewide African American community to two seat, Southern California … more specifically Black Los Angeles would have taken the hit. One of the most progressive Black populations in the nation could have found itself on the verge of being disenfranchised.

Some people think we, the African American community, are being a little too sensitive. Huh?

Well, how should we feel about it? Political representation that we’ve fought (and died for) was being threatened on questionable population premises that include undocumented aliens and historical gerrymandering. With the African American population in decline, CCRC is rationalizing that the emerging Latino and Asian communities have grown and has put the squeeze on Black representation. I don’t necessarily buy that, for a number of reasons. The Black population hasn’t declined that much. In 2020, the seat may be gone for sure, but today Blacks have to retain political power to address to dramatic political interests namely unemployment and re-entry, which I wouldn’t trust anybody else to handle. For those reasons alone, congressional representation must be retained. I’m more inclined to think it’s a power grab that Blacks in the state may never recover from.

The CCRC is playing with our community’s representation over a one percent differential in population percentage. Taking Black congressional representatives would take us from four to three, or 5.6 percent of the state’s congressional representation. So, they would rather us be underrepresented by one percent (5.6 percent) than overrepresented by one percent (at 7.5 percent). If population parity is the play, why does the CCRC still have more than 60 percent of congressional seats represented by a White person, when they are only 40.1 percent of the state’s population? Because of the way the lines are drawn and density for which majorities, namely Blacks and Latinos are clustered in urban areas.

That’s the fallacy of the population parity argument. Whites can represent other people, but other people can’t represent Whites.

It’s power that the Black community cannot afford to concede. And so the commission must know the level of alarm our community has for its district maps and encourage them to change them.

Frederick Douglass’ words never have rang truer: “Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never has and it never will.”

If the Los Angeles Black community doesn’t demand the commission retain Black political representation in Congress, it will concede Black political representation in Congress.

It is as simple as that. That’s how power shifts from one group to the next.

Anthony Asadullah Samad, Ph.D., is a national columnist, managing director of the Urban Issues Forum and author of the upcoming book, “Real Eyez: Race, Reality and Politics in 21st Century Popular Culture.” He can be reached at www.AnthonySamad.com or on Twitter at @dranthonysamad.

DISCLAIMER: The beliefs and viewpoints expressed in opinion pieces, letters to the editor, by columnists and/or contributing writers are not necessarily those of OurWeekly.

Related Articles

  • The politics of redistricting: our community is fighting on two fronts -

    The California Redistricting Commission, the first civilian redistricting effort in the state’s history, has released the first map after of the 2010 census reapportionment.

    The commission’s effort to address federal and state representation, while keeping out major party partisan politics of the usual manipulation and gerrymandering, immediately came under fire from without and within.

  • The ‘general’ plan that nobody knows about -

    In this time of government contraction, municipal services reduction and fiscal scrutiny, Los Angeles County, the nation’s largest county, is undergoing a massive revision of its General Plan.

    The General Plan represents hundreds of billions in resource allocation based on regional and local population growth forecasts that will take place over the next three decades.

  • State of the Union: A true dose of reality -

    Watching a President of the United States give a State of the Union address is often like watching a peacock strut, its head jutting forward with each step, and its splayed feathers shouting, “Look at me. I’m tall. I’m beautiful. I have it all. I did it all.”

    The president usually lists an embellished log of accomplishments and forecasts a list of unreasonable—if not unachievable—expectations. Then Congress comes back and peacocks what it has done. The president and Congress, like the peacocks, claim they can do everything but fly.

  • The King is dead. Long live the parades -

    This week is our annual King dance.

    I call it the King dance because it’s the time of year when American society dances around the significance of Martin Luther King Jr. and his contributions to the evolution of American society.

    It is really difficult to grapple with the compromising of the King legacy.

    King was more than a day off work. King marched for social justice and economic equality. He didn’t march in parades. I never got the parade concept. What are we celebrating? The life of Martin Luther King Jr., you say.

  • Iowa is over, so let’s be done with the goofiness -

    We’ve watched the Republicans drop-kick President Obama for months now… the ones in Congress, the pundits on Fox, the wannabe candidates (Palin and Trump), and the gonna-be candidates for the Republican nomination in the 2012 election.

  • Across Black America

    Here’s a look at African American people and issues making headlines throughout the country.

    California
    Allied Integrated Marketing recently announced it is launching a new African American marketing division, Allied Moxy. The new division will create innovative campaigns that integrate publicity, promotions, digital and grassroots outreach to speak directly to the full diversity of African American consumers. Spearheading Allied Moxy are industry veterans Kim Walters and Gloria Jones. Walters will oversee national strategy from Los Angeles, while Jones will oversee regional/local strategy from Washington, D.C. Walters brings more than a decade of marketing experience working with entertainment companies such as Codeblack Entertainment, Sony Pictures Home Entertainment, and A&E Lifetime Television, as well as consumer brands such as KIA and L.A. Gear and awards programs such as NAACP Image Awards and Soul Train Music Awards. Jones has been with Allied for five years running publicity and promotional campaigns for clients, including Universal Pictures, Focus Features and Relativity Media, and previously worked for WBDC-TV in D.C. and MTV Networks’ Nick @ Nite and TV Land.

     

    Representing Los Angeles and Center Theatre Group, Tyler Edwards, a senior at the Orange County High School of the Arts, placed third at the national finals of the fifth annual August Wilson Monologue Competition (AWMC) at Broadway’s August Wilson Theatre in New York City. “I am thrilled . . . I’m so glad that I took it for L.A. the first time we got up . . . that’s what we’re talking about!” said an elated Edwards following the competition. Edwards, an aspiring actor, describes the soaring, lyrical monologues found in the plays by Pulitzer Prize-winning playwright August Wilson as “very inspirational,” and said prior to the Los Angeles Regional Finals of the August Wilson competition, “I would love to share a bit of that inspiration with any audience, in hopes that they leave with more appreciation than they walked in with.”

     

    Georgia
    Bounce TV, the nation’s first-ever over-the-air broadcast television network for African Americans, will launch a second new original comedy series, “Uptown Comic,” on June 18, immediately after the series premiere of the just-announced sitcom “Family Time.” “Uptown Comic” is a half-hour series featuring stage and skit performances by some of the hottest up-and-coming comics in the country. The show is currently in production in front of a live studio audience at the longest-running African American comedy club in the U.S.—Uptown Comedy Corner in Atlanta. Actor and comedian Joe Torry (Russell Simmons’ Def Comedy Jam) hosts. “Family Time,” a half hour situation comedy created by Bentley Kyle Evans ( “The Jamie Foxx Show,” “Martin,” “Love That Girl”) and produced by Evans and partner Trenten Gumbs is set to launch Monday, June 18, at 8 p.m. The series premiere of “Uptown Comic” will follow and be seen weekly at 8:30 p.m. (All Times Eastern.)